So, you’re in the market for a sandwich toaster and want to make sure you’re getting the best one for crispy, golden toasties every time. With so many options available, choosing the right model can be a challenge. Not to worry—we’ve done the hard work for you!

In this guide, we’ve rounded up the best sandwich toasters, considering ease of use, performance, cleaning convenience, and overall value. From classic deep-fill designs to versatile panini presses, we put multiple models to the test to find the top picks for any kitchen.

After hours of toasting, crunching, and cleaning, the Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker earned our Editor’s Pick for its even heating, spacious cooking surface, and hassle-free cleanup.

Looking for a more premium? The Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker stood out with its cut-and-seal system, perfect for locking in all that cheesy goodness. And if you’re on a budget, the Global Gourmet Sandwich Toaster delivers delicious results without breaking the bank.

But not all sandwich makers impressed us. One model fell short in key areas—so if you want to avoid a frustrating purchase, we’ll tell you which one to skip. Ready to find your perfect sandwich toaster? Read on to discover the best options for your kitchen!

---

Top Features to Look for in a Sandwich Toaster

When buying the best sandwich toaster, there are certain features and qualities that should be a given to ensure you get a reliable, efficient appliance. Here’s what to look out for:

• Even Heating: Ensures consistent toasting without cold spots or burnt edges.
• Non-Stick Plates: Makes cleaning easy and prevents food from sticking.
• Quick Heating: Reaches the optimal temperature in minutes for fast, convenient use.
• Deep-Fill Capability: Allows for generously filled sandwiches without spillage.
• Secure Locking Mechanism: Keeps the toaster closed for even cooking and safety.
• Indicator Lights: Alerts you when the toaster is preheated and ready to use.
• Compact Storage: Stands upright and includes cord storage for easy storage.

Design and Build Quality

A well-designed sandwich toaster should be durable, practical, and easy to use. Here’s what to consider:

• Material Quality: Stainless steel or high-quality plastic ensures longevity and durability.
• Floating Lid: Adjusts to different sandwich thicknesses for even pressure distribution.
• Heat-Resistant Handle: Prevents burns and ensures safe handling.
• Sturdy Hinges and Latch: Avoids breakage and ensures a secure closure.
• Size and Capacity: Choose based on your needs—compact for small kitchens or larger for multiple servings.

Extra Features That Set the Best Toasters Apart

Some models offer additional features that enhance convenience and versatility. These may not be essential but can make a big difference:

• Removable Plates: Dishwasher-safe and easier to clean than fixed plates.
• Multi-Function Use: Can double as a panini press, waffle maker, or grill.
• Adjustable Temperature Control: Allows for precise toasting based on preferences.
• Drip Tray: Helps catch excess oil or melted cheese for cleaner operation.
• Interchangeable Plates: Offers different cooking surfaces for varied results.

By considering these factors, you’ll be able to find a sandwich toaster that delivers perfectly toasted bread, crispy, and delicious results every time.

---

Editors Pick

Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker | 3-Slice

The Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker is a versatile, easy-to-use appliance designed for making delicious toasties, paninis, and more. With flat non-stick plates and a floating lid, it ensures even toasting without squashing delicate breads.

Key Features

• Large Cooking Surface: Accommodates up to three paninis or two standard sandwiches.
• Floating Lid: Adjusts to different sandwich thicknesses for uniform heating.
• Flat Non-Stick Plates: No need for butter or oil, making it easy to clean.
• Quick Heating: Reaches the optimal temperature in minutes.
• Compact Storage: Stands upright and includes built-in cord storage.

The Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker is a superb choice for anyone who loves making perfectly toasted sandwiches, paninis, and more. We were highly impressed with its quick heating and consistent results—delivering crispy, golden toasties with minimal effort.

The floating lid ensures even pressure, making it ideal for a variety of breads and fillings (from paninis to ciabattas and even tortillas). The flat non-stick plates make cleaning effortless—a simple wipe-down is all it takes.

While it doesn’t seal the edges like some traditional models, this actually gives greater flexibility in what you can prepare. Its sleek stainless steel design fits well in any kitchen, and the compact upright storage is a great space-saver.

Overall, this is a reliable, well-designed sandwich press that’s easy to use, quick to clean, and perfect for everyday toasting needs.

Runner Up

Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker | 2-Slice Sandwich Toaster

The Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker is a solid choice for anyone looking to make well-filled, neatly sealed toasties. It offers extra space for ingredients, heats up quickly, and is easy to clean.

Key Features

• Deep Fill Design: With 20% more room than other Breville models, it handles both small and large slices, allowing for generous fillings.
• Cut and Seal System: Shapes the bread into triangular toasties while sealing the edges to keep the filling inside.
• Removable Non-Stick Plates: The detachable plates make cleaning effortless. They pop out easily and are dishwasher-safe.
• Compact and Practical: Stands upright for space-saving storage, with built-in cord management.
• Multi-Purpose Use: Compatible with waffle plates (sold separately), adding versatility to the kitchen.

The Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker is a fantastic choice for anyone who loves a well-filled, neatly sealed sandwich. It heats up quickly and delivers evenly toasted, golden-brown results every time.

The extra-deep plates provide plenty of space for fillings (though overstuffing can make closing tricky).

One of its standout features is the removable non-stick plates—a game-changer for easy cleaning. They pop out effortlessly and are dishwasher-safe, making post-toastie clean-up a breeze. Its compact design (with upright storage and built-in cord management) is perfect for smaller kitchens.

There are a few minor drawbacks—the handle and closing latch could feel sturdier, and the exterior gets warm during use. However, these don’t overshadow its overall performance.

Final thought? This is a well-designed, easy-to-use toastie maker that delivers delicious results with minimal fuss. It’s a top contender for any kitchen looking to level up its toasted sandwich game.

Budget Pick

Global Gourmet by Sensiohome Sandwich Toaster/Toastie Maker

The Global Gourmet Sandwich Toaster is a practical and budget-friendly choice for those who want a reliable way to make delicious toasties at home. With deep-fill plates, non-stick coating, and a compact design, it offers an easy and efficient toasting experience.

Key Features

• Deep Fill Cooking Plates: The extra-deep plates allow for a generous amount of filling, ensuring a satisfying, well-sealed toastie.
• Non-Stick Coating: Toasties release smoothly, and the plates are easy to wipe clean after use.
• Compact and Easy Storage: Cool-touch handles, a locking clasp, and built-in cord storage make it convenient to store.
• Quick and Even Heating: The toaster heats up rapidly and ensures even browning for a crisp, golden finish.
• Safety First: Features power and ready indicator lights, non-slip feet, and cool-touch handles for safe operation.

We loved the Global Gourmet Sandwich Toaster’s deep-fill plates, which allowed for generously filled toasties, sealing in all the flavours while ensuring a perfectly crisp finish. Whether it was a simple ham and oozing melted cheese or a more indulgent creation, the toaster handled it effortlessly.

Heating was fast and even, and the locking clasp kept everything neatly in place. Cleanup was hassle-free thanks to the non-stick coating—just a quick wipe, and it was good to go. While the grill plates aren’t removable (which would make cleaning even easier), we found the overall design still very user-friendly.

For an affordable, no-fuss toastie maker, this one delivers in all the right ways. If you’re after deliciously golden toasties without breaking the bank, this is a solid choice.

Best Deep Fill Pick

Tower T27013 Deep Fill Sandwich Maker with Extra Deep and Easy-to-Clean Non-Stick Ceramic Plates

The Tower T27013 Deep Fill Sandwich Maker is an excellent choice for those who love packed, flavourful toasties. Its 900W power ensures fast and even grilling, creating crispy and golden-brown results every time.

Key Features

• Deep Pocket Moulds: Easily accommodate generous fillings without spillage.
• Powerful 900W Output: Heats up quickly and cooks sandwiches evenly.
• Ceramic Non-Stick Plates: Easy to clean and require little to no oil, making for healthier sandwiches.
• Automatic Temperature Control: Prevents burning and ensures consistent toasting.
• Fits Standard Bread Slices: No need to trim edges, ensuring full coverage.
• Durable Build & Design: Sturdy and stylish, with a robust hinge for long-term use.
• Extended Warranty: Comes with a 3-year guarantee when registered online.

The Tower T27013 Deep Fill Sandwich Maker delivers exceptional performance, making it easy to create crispy, golden-brown toasties packed with flavour.

The deep pocket moulds allow for generous fillings without spillage, while the ceramic non-stick plates ensure a hassle-free clean-up (just a quick wipe while warm).

We found it fast and efficient thanks to the 900W power, heating up quickly and grilling evenly. The automatic temperature control means no constant monitoring—just pop in your sandwich and let it do the work.

One minor downside is that it stays hot for a while after use, so extra care is needed when cleaning. Also, waiting slightly beyond the ready light gives the best toastie makers results.

Overall, this reliable and well-built sandwich maker is a fantastic choice for those who love deep-filled, perfectly toasted sandwiches. It’s easy to use, simple to maintain, and great value for money.

Energy Efficient Pick

George Foreman Small Electric Fit Grill

We tested the George Foreman Small Electric Fit Grill and found it to be an excellent choice for quick, efficient cooking. Whether making toasties, grilling meat, or preparing vegetables, this grill delivers consistent results with minimal effort.

Key Benefits

• Fast Heat-Up: Ready to cook in under six minutes, reducing energy use compared to a conventional oven.
• Space-Saving Design: Compact and designed for vertical storage, making it easy to fit in any kitchen.
• Floating Hinge: Adjusts to different food thicknesses, ensuring even cooking on both sides.
• Effortless Cleaning: The non-stick plates wipe clean with a paper towel while still warm.
• Clip-in Drip Tray: Collects excess fat and juices, keeping cooking mess-free.
• Reliable Build: Sturdy design with a modern look, available in sleek black with matt finishes.

The George Foreman Small Electric Fit Grill is a fantastic choice for quick, energy-efficient sandwich toasting. It heats evenly, so there’s no need to flip food, making it perfect for toasties, grilled meats, and even vegetables.

The fast heat-up time (under six minutes) means meals are ready in no time, while the space-saving design makes it easy to store.

The floating hinge adjusts to different food thicknesses, ensuring even cooking, and the non-stick plates allow for hassle-free cleaning (a simple wipe is all it takes). The clip-in drip tray is a great touch, collecting excess fat for healthier cooking.

The only real downside is the lack of temperature control, meaning you rely on its preset heat. Also, the plates aren’t removable, but cleaning is still straightforward.

For a compact, reliable, and efficient grill toaster that consistently delivers great results, this is a top contender in any kitchen.

One To Avoid

Belaco Sandwich Maker 2 Slice Sandwich Toaster Machine

We put the Belaco 2 Slice Sandwich Maker to the test, and unfortunately, it falls short in several key areas. While it heats up quickly and the non-stick plates make cleaning simple, these minor positives don’t make up for its fundamental design flaws.

The biggest issue is its size. The plates are too small to fit standard bread, meaning slices have to be trimmed or forced inside, leading to uneven toasting and a frustrating experience.

The interlocking handle, designed to press sandwiches together, struggles to close properly, especially with thicker fillings. It often requires extra pressure, which isn't ideal for a device meant to be convenient.

Storage is one of its few advantages, as its compact design makes it easy to tuck away. However, this also contributes to its impracticality—there simply isn’t enough room to make a proper sandwich without parts of the bread sticking out.

The handle also feels flimsy and doesn’t inspire confidence in its durability.

While it’s an affordable option, the compromises in size, usability, and build quality make it hard to recommend. If you want a sandwich maker that actually fits standard bread and performs reliably, it’s best to look elsewhere.

How We Tested and Selected the Best Sandwich Toasters

Choosing the best sandwich toaster requires more than just making a few toasties and calling it a day. We took a close look at performance, ease of use, build quality, and extra features to find the best models on the market. Here’s how we did it.

Performance Testing

A sandwich toaster should produce crispy, evenly toasted sandwiches without burnt edges or cold spots. We tested how well each model handled different types of bread, including white, whole grain, and ciabatta.

Toasting speed was measured, ensuring each appliance delivered golden, crunchy results in a reasonable time. Fillings were also considered—we checked for leakage, even melting, and how well the toaster adapted to various ingredients.

For models with a cut-and-seal function, we ensured fillings stayed enclosed while maintaining a satisfying crunch.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

A good sandwich toaster should be simple to operate. We evaluated how intuitive the setup was, checking whether the lid adjusted smoothly to different sandwich sizes. Secure latches were tested for stability, ensuring a firm hold during cooking.

Cleaning was another priority—non-stick plates were wiped down to see how easily food residue came off. For toasters with removable plates, we tested how easily they detached and whether they were dishwasher-safe, making post-toastie cleanup as effortless as possible.

Build Quality and Durability

A durable sandwich toaster should feel sturdy and well-constructed. We examined the materials, prioritising models made from stainless steel over lightweight plastic. The handle and hinges were tested for strength, ensuring they didn’t feel flimsy.

We also checked whether the exterior became too hot during use, as some models posed a burn risk. Storage convenience was another consideration—compact designs with upright storage and cord management were rated higher for saving kitchen space.

Extra Features

Beyond basic functionality, some toasters offer added versatility. We tested models with adjustable temperature settings to see if they allowed for better crisp control. Toasters that doubled as panini presses or waffle makers were assessed for their effectiveness across different foods.

Indicator lights were checked for accuracy, ensuring they clearly signaled when the toaster was ready. Cool-touch handles and safety features were also evaluated to see if they improved the overall user experience, making handling the toaster more convenient and secure.

Value for Money

Price doesn’t always reflect quality, so we compared features and performance to determine overall value. Some models stood out for their reliability, ease of use, and versatility, while others disappointed due to uneven toasting or poor build quality.

Those that lacked durability, overheated, or failed to deliver consistent results were noted as ones to avoid. After considering all these factors, we selected the best sandwich toasters that provide excellent performance, durability, and convenience at a fair price.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Difference Between a Bread Toaster and a Sandwich Toaster?

The difference between a bread toaster and a sandwich toaster lies in their functionality and design.

A bread toaster is designed for toasting plain slices of bread vertically, while a sandwich toaster allows for making filled sandwiches by heating and sealing the ingredients between two plates, often creating a crisp, golden finish.

Do Sandwich Toasters Use a Lot of Electricity?

Sandwich toasters do not use a lot of electricity compared to larger kitchen appliances. Most models operate at around 700-1,500 watts, which is similar to a standard bread toaster.

Since they heat up quickly and cook in just a few minutes, their energy consumption remains relatively low for occasional use.

What Is the Best Bread for Sandwich Toasters?

The best bread for sandwich toasters is sturdy and thick enough to hold fillings without becoming too soggy. Medium to thick-cut white, wholemeal, or sourdough bread works well, as they toast evenly and maintain structure.

Softer breads may compress too much, while dense artisan loaves may take longer to crisp up.

Can You Use Frozen Bread in a Sandwich Toaster?

You can use frozen bread in a sandwich toaster, though results may vary. Some toasters handle frozen slices well, while others may require slightly longer cooking times. If using frozen bread, it is best to add slightly less filling to ensure even toasting, as moisture from defrosting can affect crispiness.

Is It OK to Defrost Bread in a Toaster?

It is generally OK to defrost bread in a toaster, but it depends on the appliance. Some toasters have a dedicated defrost function that gradually warms the bread before toasting. However, using a sandwich toaster to defrost bread is less ideal, as it may lead to uneven heating and excess moisture buildup.

Do You Preheat a Sandwich Toaster?

Yes, you should preheat a sandwich toaster before use. Most models require a few minutes to reach the optimal temperature, ensuring even toasting and preventing food from sticking. Preheating also helps achieve a crispier texture and shortens cooking time, leading to better results overall.

How Do You Keep Bread from Sticking to a Sandwich Toaster?

To keep bread from sticking to a sandwich toaster, ensure the plates are clean and lightly greased if necessary. Most toasters have a non-stick coating, but a small amount of butter or oil can help. Using bread with a slightly drier texture and avoiding overly wet fillings also reduces sticking.

---

Final Word

Hopefully, our best sandwich toaster guide has helped you find the perfect model for your kitchen. With so many great options, choosing one isn’t easy, but we do have a favourite.

The Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker is our top pick, thanks to its spacious design, even heating, and easy cleaning. Whether you love crispy toasties or gourmet paninis, this model delivers excellent results with minimal effort.

If you prefer a deep-fill design, the Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker is another standout, while the Global Gourmet Sandwich Toaster is a solid budget-friendly choice.

However, one model didn’t make the cut. The Belaco 2 Slice Sandwich Maker is one to avoid due to its undersized plates, flimsy handle, and impractical design. While compact and affordable, it simply doesn’t perform well.

Found your perfect sandwich toaster, or still deciding? Let us know in the comments—we’d love to hear from you!