Looking for the perfect toastie maker to upgrade your sandwich game? With countless options available, finding the right one can be overwhelming. Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered!

We’ve tested and reviewed the best toastie makers on the market, whether you want quick snacks, family-sized solutions, or budget-friendly tools that deliver delicious results.

From versatile sandwich presses to compact stovetop options, we evaluated each product based on ease of use, efficiency, durability, and the quality of those golden, crispy toasties.

Our Editor’s Pick, the Breville Sandwich Press, stood out for its sleek design and ability to handle everything from paninis to wraps. Feeding a crowd? The Tower T27021 4-Slice Deep Fill Toastie Maker earned our Runner-Up spot with its powerful performance and extra capacity.

On a budget? The QINGLANG Double-Sided Frying Pan Toastie Maker impressed us with its versatility and compact design, ideal for smaller kitchens or camping trips.

Not all options passed the test. The PIFCO 750W Sandwich Toaster left us disappointed with its limited functionality and uneven toasting, making it a product to avoid. Ready to find your perfect toastie maker? Keep reading for our top picks and take your sandwiches to the next level!

---

The Ultimate Guide to Toastie Maker Features

When shopping for the best toastie maker, there are certain features and functionalities you should expect as a standard. These are the "must-haves" that ensure your purchase delivers on quality and convenience:

Features That Should Be a Given

• Non-Stick Sandwich Plates: For easy cleaning and less mess after use.
• Even Heating: Ensures both sides of your toastie are perfectly cooked without cold spots.
• Compact Size: Easy to store, especially for smaller kitchens. Upright easy storage is a plus.
• Cool-Touch Handle: For safe handling while the machine is in use.
• Quick Heat-Up Time: Saves you time, especially for quick snacks.
• Automatic Temperature Control: Maintains consistent heating without manual adjustments.
• Durable Build: A sturdy design that withstands regular use.
• Indicator Lights: Letting you know when the device is preheated and ready to use.

Norms to Look Out For

• Floating Lid or Adjustable Height: Accommodates different bread sizes, from thin wraps to thick slices.
• Cord Storage: For a neat and tidy kitchen counter.
• Capacity Options: Choose between single, double, or family-sized models to suit your needs.

Design and Build Quality

A well-designed toastie maker should combine functionality with durability and style. Key aspects of design and build quality include:

• Material: High-quality stainless steel or die-cast aluminium ensures longevity and even heating.
• Weight: A balanced weight is ideal—sturdy enough to stay stable during use but not too heavy to move around.
• Ergonomics: Easy-to-use handles, buttons, and controls enhance user experience.
• Heat Insulation: Properly insulated outer surfaces prevent accidental burns.
• Aesthetic Appeal: A sleek, modern look complements your kitchen design while being functional.

Enhance Your Toastie Game with These Extra Features

Some toastie makers come with bonus features that add versatility and convenience to your cooking experience. While not essential, these extras can make your purchase even more worthwhile:

• Removable Plates: Allow for easier cleaning and versatility in cooking styles (e.g., grilling or waffle plates).
• Multi-Functionality: Some models can double as grills for other foods like vegetables, meats, or quesadillas.
• Custom Heat Settings: Options to control temperature for different bread types or fillings.
• Deep-Fill Capacity: Ensures your sandwiches hold more filling without spilling.
• Digital Displays: For precise temperature and timer settings.
• Compatibility: Models that work with various heat sources (e.g., stovetop options for camping).
• Recipe Booklets or Apps: Bonus resources for trying out new creations.

By keeping these expectations, norms, and features in mind, you’ll be equipped to choose a toastie maker that fits your needs and delivers perfectly toasted sandwiches every time.

---

Editors Pick

Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker

The Breville Sandwich Press is a versatile and practical addition to any kitchen. We tested it for a variety of uses, and it consistently delivered great results.

Key Features

• Fits Different Bread Thicknesses: The floating lid accommodates various bread sizes, from thin wraps to thick ciabattas. It toasts evenly without crushing the bread.
• Quick and Efficient: The press heats up quickly and provides even browning, making delicious paninis, sandwiches, or even delicate items like croissants in just minutes.
• Non-Stick Plates: The flat, non-stick aluminium plates are easy to clean. A simple wipe-down after cooling is usually enough.
• Compact and Space-Saving: It stands upright for storage and includes cord management, making it ideal for smaller kitchens.
• Durable Design: The brushed stainless steel finish is not only stylish but also easy to maintain.

We found the Breville Sandwich Press to be an incredibly reliable and versatile kitchen tool. It’s simple to use and produces consistently great results, whether we were making paninis, sandwiches, or warming flatbreads like tortillas and naan.

The floating lid is a standout feature, easily accommodating various bread thicknesses while ensuring even toasting. The non-stick plates make cleanup effortless, and the compact design (complete with upright storage and cord management) is perfect for smaller kitchens.

We also appreciated the cool-touch handle, which added a layer of safety during use. One minor downside we noticed was that the top plate gets slightly hotter than the bottom. For perfectly even browning, flipping the sandwich halfway through worked well.

Overall, the Breville Sandwich Press is a fantastic addition to any kitchen. Its efficiency, ease of use, and sleek design make it an excellent choice for anyone who enjoys quick, delicious meals.

Runner Up

Tower T27021 4-Slice Deep Fill Sandwich Maker

The Tower T27021 4-Slice Deep Fill Sandwich Maker delivers on its promise of efficient, easy-to-use functionality. We’ve tested it extensively and found it to be an excellent addition to any kitchen, particularly for families or anyone needing quick, satisfying meals.

Key Features

• Fast and Efficient: With a powerful 1800W, it grills sandwiches quickly, saving time during busy mornings or lunch breaks.
• Deep-Fill Capacity: Accommodates up to four deep-filled sandwiches at once, making it ideal for larger households.
• Easy to Clean: The non-stick plates ensure minimal mess, requiring just a quick wipe while still warm to keep it looking and functioning like new.
• Automatic Temperature Control: Delivers consistently toasted results without the need for manual adjustments.
• Safe and Comfortable to Use: The cool-touch handle provides a secure grip, making operation hassle-free.

We’ve found the Tower T27021 4-Slice Deep Fill Sandwich Maker to be an exceptional addition to our kitchen. Its powerful 1800W heating ensures quick and efficient grilling, while the extra-deep non-stick plates make healthier, low-oil cooking a breeze (perfect for those watching their intake).

The capacity is impressive—it easily makes four deep-filled sandwiches at once, ideal for feeding a group or family. We also appreciated how neatly it seals sandwiches, minimising spillage. While its larger size might catch your eye initially, it’s well-suited for the task and accommodates standard bread sizes perfectly.

The only downside we noted is the absence of removable plates, which would make cleaning even easier. However, the non-stick surface is straightforward to wipe clean, so it’s a minor inconvenience at most.

Overall, this sandwich maker combines speed, versatility, and quality, making it a worthwhile investment for anyone who loves perfectly toasted sandwiches.

Budget Pick

QINGLANG Double Side Bread Frying Pan Toastie Maker

The QINGLANG Double-Sided Bread Frying Pan Toastie Maker is a versatile and efficient kitchen tool. We’ve tested it extensively, and it delivers on its promises. Here's what we found:

Key Features

• High-Quality Build: Made of die-cast aluminium, it’s sturdy and durable. The material ensures quick, even heating for consistent cooking results.
• Non-Stick Coating: The non-stick surface makes cooking and cleaning effortless. It reduces the need for oil, minimises mess, and keeps cooking healthier.
• Insulated Handle: The heat-resistant handle provides a comfortable, secure grip. Its non-slip design allows for safe and easy flipping, ensuring even cooking on both sides.
• Wide Compatibility: Works seamlessly on gas, electric, halogen, and ceramic stoves. This versatility makes it a great addition to any kitchen or camping gear.

We found the QINGLANG Double-Sided Bread Frying Pan Toastie Maker to be an incredibly versatile and practical kitchen tool. Its efficient design and robust construction make cooking easy and enjoyable.

The die-cast aluminium body ensures fast, even heating, while the non-stick coating prevents mess and makes cleaning simple (a huge time-saver!). The deep structure allows for generously filled sandwiches without leaks, and the insulated, non-slip handle feels secure and stays cool during use.

It’s also compact, so it doesn’t take up much storage space—a big plus for smaller kitchens or camping gear. While it works beautifully on various stoves, we noticed that it performs best on low to medium heat for optimal results.

Overall, this toastie maker is a reliable, durable, and efficient tool for both quick meals and hearty snacks. Its versatility and ease of use make it a fantastic addition to any kitchen.

Lightweight Pick

Global Gourmet by Sensiohome Sandwich Toaster

We recently tried the Global Gourmet by Sensiohome Sandwich Toaster, and it exceeded our expectations. Here's what we discovered:

Key Features

• Deep Fill Toasties: The deeper cooking plates allow for a generous amount of filling, perfect for creating satisfying sandwiches without the mess.
• Quick Results: Within minutes, it produces two golden-brown toasties, ideal for a quick snack or meal.
• Non-Stick Plates: Cleaning is simple. Once cooled, a soft, damp cloth easily wipes away any residue.
• Compact Storage: Its locking clasp, cord storage, and cool-touch handles make it easy to tuck away neatly in any kitchen.
• User-Friendly Design: LED indicators for power and readiness, along with non-slip feet, add a layer of safety and convenience.

What stood out to us was its ability to seal and cut sandwiches effectively. No need to grab a knife—the toaster does the job for you. It’s also well-suited for deep fillings like oozing melted cheese and beans, keeping everything securely inside.

Cleaning is straightforward, though we recommend wiping it down soon after use to prevent grease from hardening. This small step makes maintenance effortless. The design is sturdy, and it accommodates standard slices of bread without issue.

While it may not handle larger slices perfectly, this is a minor inconvenience considering its overall performance. This sandwich toaster combines thoughtful design with practical features, making it a great addition to any kitchen.

Whether you're preparing a quick snack or indulging in a comforting toastie, this appliance delivers reliable results every time. If you're looking for a simple, effective sandwich toaster that offers value for money, we believe this one is worth considering.

Energy Efficient Pick

George Foreman Immersa Small Electric Grill Toastie Maker

The George Foreman Immersa Small Electric Grill offers a practical and efficient way to cook healthier meals with less hassle. After using it, we found its features thoughtfully designed for everyday convenience.

Key Features

• Easy Cleaning - Dishwasher Safe: The removable hinge and control panel let you fully submerge the grill or place it in the dishwasher—no more scrubbing.
• Compact and Convenient: Its small size suits tight spaces and is easy to store and handle.
• Energy Efficient: Uses 77% less energy than a conventional oven, cutting costs and being eco-friendly.
• Faster Preheat: Heats 52% quicker than older models, perfect for quick meals.
• Fat Draining System: A drip tray and drainage holes efficiently remove fat for cleaner cooking.

We found the George Foreman Immersa Grill to be a practical and user-friendly addition to any kitchen. It consistently cooks a variety of foods, from burgers to vegetables, with ease and precision.

The innovative design (flat plates that prevent food from sliding) and the efficient fat-draining system make it a standout choice for healthier cooking.

Cleaning is effortless thanks to the dishwasher-safe components, a feature we absolutely loved. The simple control panel (on/off switch and temperature indicator) makes it accessible for everyone.

However, the lack of adjustable temperature settings requires close attention during cooking to avoid overcooking or drying out food. Its compact size is perfect for small portions but might feel limiting for larger households.

Despite these minor drawbacks, the grill's convenience, energy efficiency, and overall performance outweigh its limitations. It's a smart choice for anyone seeking hassle-free, healthier meals with minimal cleanup.

One To Avoid

PIFCO 750W White Non-Stick Sandwich Toaster

The PIFCO 750W White Non-Stick Sandwich Toaster seemed promising for quick snacks, especially in small kitchens. Its compact design (ideal for tight spaces) and lightweight build were highlights. The non-stick plates made cleaning straightforward, and the cool-touch handle felt safe to use.

However, significant drawbacks emerged during testing. The toaster's small size limits its functionality—standard-sized bread doesn't fit properly, leading to overhangs and uneven toasting.

This makes it impractical for most bread options, even smaller slices. While it heats up quickly, the limited capacity and lack of flexibility for filled sandwiches were disappointing.

Despite its few positives, we found the toaster more frustrating than functional. For those looking for a reliable sandwich maker, this falls short of expectations. In the end, the compact design sacrifices too much usability, making this a product we’d avoid.

How We Tested and Chose the Best Sandwich Toasters

When evaluating toastie makers, we went beyond just making a few sandwiches. Every aspect that contributes to a great user experience was meticulously tested. Here’s how we determined the top models on the market.

Design and Build Quality

We started by assessing the design and materials of each toastie maker. Durability was a key factor, as we looked for high-quality materials like stainless steel or aluminium that could withstand regular use.

We also evaluated the size and storage options, noting whether the unit could be stored upright or included features like cord storage for added convenience. Safety was paramount, so we tested handles to ensure they stayed cool during operation and checked insulation to prevent burns.

Lastly, the overall style and aesthetics were considered, looking for designs that could complement a modern kitchen.

Toasting Performance

To ensure each toastie maker delivered on its primary purpose, we tested its ability to produce evenly browned sandwiches. Various bread types and thicknesses were used, from thin wraps to thick ciabattas, to check for versatility.

Cooking times were measured to see how quickly the toasties reached a crispy golden finish, and consistency was evaluated across repeated uses to ensure reliable performance.

Usability

Ease of use was another critical area of focus. We looked at how straightforward it was to set up and operate each model. Controls such as preheat indicators or temperature settings were tested for simplicity and functionality.

Cleaning the plates was a key factor—non-stick surfaces were a must, and we noted whether the plates were removable for easier maintenance. Storage was also considered, especially for those with limited kitchen space.

Versatility

We pushed the limits of each toastie maker by trying various foods beyond standard sandwiches, including paninis, croissants, quesadillas, and flatbreads. Capacity was tested to see how well single or multiple sandwiches could be prepared, catering to both individual users and families.

Any extra features, such as temperature control, multi-purpose use, or removable plates, were evaluated to determine how much value they added to the overall experience.

Safety and Efficiency

The safety and efficiency of each model were carefully tested. We measured how quickly the plates heated up to their optimal cooking temperature and checked for consistent heat stability during operation.

Features like cool-touch handles, auto shut-off, and stable footing were thoroughly assessed to ensure safe use, especially for families with children.

Value for Money

Finally, we compared each toastie maker’s performance and features against its price. Durability was an important factor here; we simulated long-term use by making multiple toasties to assess wear and tear. This helped identify which models provided the best overall value for their cost.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Difference Between a Toaster and a Toastie Maker?

The difference between a toaster and a toastie maker lies in their functionality. A toaster browns slices of bread evenly on both sides while a toastie maker presses and heats sandwiches, often sealing the edges. Toastie makers allow for filled, hot sandwiches, while toasters are ideal for plain bread.

Is a Sandwich Press the Same as a Toastie Maker?

A sandwich press is not exactly the same as a toastie maker. A sandwich press typically features flat plates for grilling and toasting sandwiches, while a toastie maker often has grooved plates to seal and shape sandwiches into a pocket-like design. Both serve similar purposes but cater to different styles.

Do Toastie Makers Use a Lot of Electricity?

Toastie makers generally do not use a lot of electricity. They are designed for short cooking durations and operate at moderate power levels, making them energy-efficient kitchen appliances.

Their electricity usage depends on wattage, but they typically consume less energy than larger cooking devices.

What Else Can You Cook in a Toastie Maker?

You can cook a variety of foods in a toastie maker beyond sandwiches. These include quesadillas, omelettes, hash browns, waffles, and even grilled vegetables. Some models are versatile enough to handle flatbreads, pastries, and other quick snacks, depending on their plate design and features.

Which Coating Is Best for a Sandwich Maker?

The best coating for a sandwich maker is a non-stick surface. Non-stick coatings make cleaning easier, prevent food from sticking, and allow for healthier cooking with little to no added oil. Look for durable, high-quality, non-stick materials that resist wear over time.

Is It Important to Oil a Toastie Maker Before Using It?

It is not always important to oil a toastie maker before using it. If the plates are non-stick, oiling is usually unnecessary and could lead to a greasy buildup. However, a light coating of oil might be beneficial for crispier results or when using older models without non-stick surfaces.

---

Final Word

Hopefully, our guide to the best toastie makers has made choosing your ideal kitchen companion easier. With so many great options, picking a favourite is tough, but the Breville Sandwich Press stands out as our top pick.

Its sleek design, versatility, and ability to deliver perfectly toasted sandwiches make it a fantastic choice for any kitchen. From paninis to wraps, it handles everything with ease.

While most of our recommendations are excellent, there’s one to avoid—the PIFCO 750W Sandwich Toaster. Despite its compact size, it struggles with uneven toasting, limited functionality, and doesn’t accommodate standard bread well. It’s unlikely to meet the needs of toastie enthusiasts.

What did you think of our guide? Have you found your perfect toastie maker, or are you still deciding? Let us know in the comments—we’d love to hear your thoughts!